Dealing with Difficult Tenants in Your Charleston Rental Property

March 02, 2023 | By Charleston Property Company
A property manager handles challenging renters in a Charleston rental property

Updated March 2, 2023

Even when operating quality rental homes that attract quality tenants (most of the time), there is still a good chance you have dealt with some difficult ones. Although this is considered part of being a landlord, difficult tenants can cause you stress and anxiety.

The actions of tenants with little regard for your Charleston rental property will affect you and any other tenants you may have. As such, it is vital to find ways of dealing with those proven to be troublesome. While there are no easy solutions for managing difficult tenants, there are several steps that you can take to try and work something out. 

Here are a few tips to help you handle sticky situations with your most disruptive tenants.

What Do Bad Renters Do?

Have you dealt with any of the following? If so, you may have wondered how to handle these situations appropriately (while losing money in the meantime).

  • Late rent every month

  • Careless damage caused to your property

  • Failure to follow your policies

  • Disturbances on your property or issues with neighbors.

While there is no way to never deal with any of these issues as a property owner, it is possible to handle these situations well and reduce the frequency of how often they happen!

1. Do Your Due DiligencePhoto of a rental application and pen.

One of the best ways to deal with a troublesome tenant is not dealing with them in the first place. To achieve this, landlords and property managers should do their due diligence during the screening process to avoid some common pitfalls before they rent out their properties.

Take the time to conduct tenant screening and thoroughly check and verify the employment history, credit report, and rental references of the applicant. Proper screening will go a long way in helping you weed out issues and avoid many problems. If you already have a screening process in place, diagnose weak spots that allow risky renters like "Professional Tenants" to slip through the cracks.

Another fantastic alternative is to work with the best property management company Charleston offers to help handle your screening needs whenever tenant placement time rolls around. Property management professionals are experts in thoroughly vetting renters.

2. Remain Calm and Keep It Professional

Since most difficult renters will want to manipulate you and play with your emotions, you must ensure that you are calm, objective, and rational when dealing with them.

Although it is easy to get angry with such tenants, this will only make the situation worse. Instead, try to be polite but firm, making sure that emotions do not cloud your thoughts as you explain to the tenant the problems they are causing you.

Even more crucially, keep all communication through official, documented channels. The old adage "get it in writing" exists for a reason! If worse comes to worst, you'll have the evidence you need to shield yourself and your assets.

Although keeping written records of everything will increase your workload, it will go a long way in helping to avoid conflicts with your tenants. Try to document all payments, complaints, charges, and interactions between you and the residents. In addition to proper documentation, you should also take pictures and videos so that the tenant does not dispute any necessary deductions.

Depending on the situation, you may need to take time and calm down if you get too worked up. Most renters will be more receptive if you approach them in a collected and courteous way. If you feel like you've gotten emotionally compromised, you can always bring in a Charleston property manager to tactfully take care of the issue.

3. Craft a Rock-Solid Lease

A thorough lease agreement helps property owners deal with difficult renters.

Set some ground rules for what you expect from your tenant's behavior from the very beginning with an air-tight lease.

When you use a prefabricated lease, you give tenants the opportunity for wiggle room when enforcement time rolls around. Unfortunately, many of those cookie-cutter lease forms you can find for free online are rife with language that damages landlords.

A Charleston property manager can be your secret weapon when it comes to creating a lease agreement that protects you and your rental property and helps you maximize revenue: they are well-versed in state and local property law, and they know what language you need to create the perfect lease.

Having standards from the outset will ensure that all residents know what is expected of them. The criteria should relate to their behavior, payment, resolving issues, and anything else. Part of this will include defined business hours during which they can make non-emergency inquiries.

4. Eviction Is a Last Resort

As property managers, we always recommend removal only as a last resort. However, if it comes to this, the information you gathered earlier in tip #2 will go a long way toward supporting your choice to evict if the tenant chooses to take you to court.

However, there are some alternatives to this method you can try first, like "cash for keys," to get a truly troublesome tenant out of your Charleston rental property.

Property owners should only pursue an eviction with the advice of competent legal counsel or the aid of a trusted property manager. Tackling this one alone often ends up as a very expensive option for new landlords.

A Charleston Property Manager Is Your Ally

No matter how hard you try to please them, some tenants will just be hard to deal with. When you find yourself in such a situation, you should consider hiring a property manager.

Hiring a property manager will not only help to eliminate the associated stress but also give you more time to attend to other issues. When looking for a reliable property management professional, ask about their experience and the specific services they offer. While you can choose to deal with troubled tenants on your own, a property manager paves the way to reliable success—especially if you plan on adding more properties to your portfolio!

Reach out to Charleston Property Company to learn more about how we help property owners handle challenging renter situations. We can also help you make sure you're generating the revenue you should with a Free Rental Analysis. This service includes a market analysis that can help you identify the ideal monthly rent amount for your property!


Latest Posts

Subscribe to Our Blog

Subscribe to receive the latest news and tips about property management.

Subscribe Here!

Landlord Tips

Should I Show a Rental Property While a Resident Still Lives There?

Updated May 12, 2023 Scheduling and conducting rental property showings can be ...

By Charleston Property Company

Landlord 101: Understanding the Section 8 Program in Charleston

February 17, 2015 by Albert Fontenot If you are new to the South Carolina real ...

By Albert Fontenot

6 Steps to Renting Out Your Charleston, SC, Home for the First Time

Stepping into the realm of real estate and becoming a landlord can be an ...

By Charleston Property Company

How Much Do Charleston Property Managers Cost?

Updated February 7, 2023 Today we are talking about how much professional ...

By Charleston Property Company

Our Expert Tips for Pet-Friendly Rental Properties in Charleston

Published January 30, 2020. Updated August 29, 2023. Are you considering ...

By Charleston Property Company

Similar Posts

Turn That Spare Home Into a Rental With a Charleston Property Manager!

September 17, 2020  |  By Charleston Property Company

Do you have plans to move into a different home—but you would prefer not to sell your current home? You're not alone: many homeowners are looking for ...

Landlord 101: Being Professional

January 03, 2015  |  By Albert Fontenot

January 2, 2015 by Albert Fontenot Last month in Columbus a woman by the name of Anita Anderson rented a home, dutifully paid the landlord her first ...

Making Your Charleston Rental Property Attractive to Millennials

March 09, 2023  |  By Charleston Property Company

Updated March 9, 2023 As a group, millennials (including "affluent" millennials) have been moving away from homeownership and towards renting. We'll ...